Former Penn State team doctor alleges James Franklin attempted to interfere with medical decisions
Dr. Pete Seidenberg claims Franklin and AD Sandy Barbour pushed to medically disqualify a player who attempted suicide.
During the highly publicized trial, Lynch vs. Hershey Medical Center, attorney Steven F. Marino utilized this and other examples to argue that Lynch was “all-in” on his medical autonomy, leading to retaliation and his subsequent ouster from the team. The jury ultimately awarded Dr. Lynch $5.25 million in damages.

James Franklin watches on during football practice at the Lasch Practice Field by NoahRiffe. Contact Photographer @ Noahriffephoto.com (license: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/)
A former Penn State team doctor alleges that coach James Franklin attempted to interfere with medical decisions involving players on the team, according to testimony obtained by John Luciew of PennLive.com.
Dr. Pete Seidenberg, the primary care doctor for Penn State’s football team in 2014, claimed during a civil trial against Franklin and the school that he was pushed by Franklin and athletic director Sandy Barbour to medically disqualify a player who attempted suicide in order to free up a scholarship. The unidentified player was in short-term psychiatric care.
“I perceived that as his attempt to influence medical decisions,” Seidenberg said.
Seidenberg added that he declined to give into the pressure from Franklin and Barbour. He included other instances in which he thought Franklin overstepped in trying to get his way on medical decisions, involving both himself and former director of athletic medicine Dr. Scott Lynch. The lawsuit was filed by Lynch, who alleges his unwillingness to go along with Franklin’s desires played a key role in his termination in March 2019.
Seidenberg no longer works at Penn State and practices medicine outside of Pennsylvania.
Lynch filed the lawsuit months after his dismissal and revised the complaint in 2021. Franklin himself was removed as a defendant in 2020 due to statute of limitations, so the lawsuit is directed at Penn State’s Milton S. Hershey Medical Center and Dr. Kevin Black, who gave his dismissal.
Franklin has been at Penn State since 2014 with an 88-39 overall record. In 2023, he signed a 10-year guaranteed contract that will pay him more than $70 million.
Employers who violate the law should be held accountable. If you were wrongfully terminated because of discrimination, retaliation, whistleblowing, or another unlawful reason, Marino Associates is prepared to investigate your claim, preserve critical evidence, and aggressively pursue the compensation and justice you deserve. Call ( (215) 462-3200 or complete our online contact form to speak with an experienced wrongful termination attorney today. Your case consultation is free.
Publisher
Published By: CBS Sports, May 22, 2024 | By Shehan Jeyarajah
Related Posts
Pennlive’s John Luciew, Interviews Dr. Scott Lynch and attorney, Steven F. Marino
Pennlive's John Luciew, Interviews Dr. Scott Lynch and attorney, Steven F. Marino Dr. Scott Lynch and attorney Steven Marino, speak to PennLive at the Hershey home of plaintiff, Dr. Scott [...]
Penn State found ‘friction’ between coach James Franklin, team doctor; could not determine violation
Penn State found ‘friction’ between coach James Franklin, team doctor; could not determine violation The Associated Press obtained a leaked 2019 internal Penn State review known as the "Boland Report". [...]
Nike contract with Penn State scrutinized at trial for fired football doctor
Nike contract with Penn State scrutinized as recent developments have drawn national attention. This latest Nike contract with Penn State scrutinized story is prompting increased debate and analysis at every level. [...]
Secret report on Franklin at center of fired Penn State football doctor’s trial
Secret report on Franklin at center of fired Penn State football doctor’s trial Lynch’s attorney, Steven F. Marino, suggested in court the trustees didn’t receive a detailed enough briefing, suggesting [...]



